Choosing the right hardwood flooring involves more than just selecting a wood species and finish—plank width plays a significant role in how a space looks and functions. Both narrow and wide plank hardwood flooring offer distinct aesthetic and practical benefits, influencing everything from installation time to long-term maintenance.
While narrow planks have been a traditional choice for decades, wide planks have gained popularity in modern and luxury homes. Homeowners often wonder which option is best for their space, but the answer depends on various factors, including room size, style preference, and budget. Understanding the key differences between these two options will help you make the best decision for your home.
Related Article: What Hardwood Floor Installation Patterns Are Going to Rule in 2025?
What Is Narrow Plank Hardwood Flooring?
Narrow plank hardwood flooring typically refers to boards that are less than 3 inches wide. This type of flooring has been a staple in homes for years, offering a clean, classic look that suits various interior styles.
Benefits of Narrow Plank Hardwood Flooring
- Traditional and Versatile Aesthetic – Narrow planks provide a uniform, refined look that blends seamlessly with both classic and modern interiors.
- More Seamless Appearance – Because there are more planks per square foot, narrow plank flooring creates a consistent visual flow with fewer noticeable gaps.
- Greater Stability in Changing Climates – Narrow planks expand and contract less with temperature and humidity fluctuations, making them a great choice for regions with varying seasonal conditions.
- Easier to Replace or Repair – If a board gets damaged, replacing a single narrow plank is easier and less noticeable compared to wide planks.
Drawbacks of Narrow Plank Hardwood Flooring
- Longer Installation Time – More planks mean more seams, requiring additional time for alignment and fastening during installation.
- Busier Visual Appearance – A higher number of seams can create a more intricate or “busy” look, which may not be suitable for those preferring a minimalist aesthetic.
What Is Wide Plank Hardwood Flooring?
Wide plank hardwood flooring consists of boards that are typically 5 to 12 inches wide. This style is often associated with rustic, farmhouse, and high-end contemporary designs due to its ability to showcase natural wood grain and character.
Benefits of Wide Plank Hardwood Flooring
- Luxurious and Modern Appeal – Wide planks create a bold, expansive look, making them a preferred choice in luxury homes and modern interior designs.
- Fewer Seams, More Cohesive Appearance – With fewer boards per square foot, wide plank flooring appears more continuous and seamless, enhancing the spaciousness of a room.
- Enhanced Wood Grain Visibility – The larger surface area of each plank highlights the wood’s natural patterns, knots, and textures, adding depth and character to the flooring.
- Faster Installation – With fewer planks required to cover the same area, installation is often quicker and less labour-intensive.
Drawbacks of Wide Plank Hardwood Flooring
- More Susceptible to Expansion and Contraction – Because wide planks cover more surface area, they tend to expand and contract more noticeably with humidity changes, potentially leading to gapping or cupping.
- Higher Material and Installation Costs – Wide planks are often more expensive because they require larger sections of high-quality wood. Professional installation may be necessary to prevent warping.
- Not Ideal for Small Spaces – In compact rooms, wide planks can sometimes make the space feel visually heavy or disproportionate.
Related Article: How to Fill Gaps in Hardwood Floors
Key Differences Between Narrow and Wide Plank Hardwood Flooring
Both narrow and wide plank flooring have their own unique appeal, but they differ significantly in various aspects.
- Aesthetic Appeal – Narrow planks offer a classic and symmetrical look, while wide planks create a bold and spacious effect with fewer seams.
- Seam Visibility – More seams in narrow plank flooring create a uniform texture, whereas wide planks reduce the number of seams for a cleaner, more open look.
- Installation Process – Narrow planks require more time and effort to install due to their smaller size, whereas wide planks cover more area per board, making installation quicker.
- Durability and Climate Resistance – Narrow planks are less prone to expansion and contraction, making them a better choice in regions with fluctuating humidity levels. Wide planks require careful acclimation before installation to prevent movement over time.
- Room Suitability – Narrow planks work well in small to medium-sized rooms, helping maintain proportionality, while wide planks shine in large, open-concept spaces.
- Cost Considerations – Narrow plank flooring tends to be more budget-friendly due to easier sourcing and production, whereas wide planks are considered a premium option due to the amount of high-quality wood required.
Related Article: How to Prepare Your Home for Hardwood Floor Installation
Which Option Is Best for Your Home?
The choice between narrow and wide plank hardwood flooring depends on various factors, including your home’s size, style, and personal preferences.
Narrow Plank Flooring Is Best If You:
- Prefer a timeless, traditional look that works with any decor.
- Want flooring that is more resistant to humidity changes.
- Have a smaller room and want a balanced, seamless appearance.
- Are looking for a cost-effective option with easier maintenance and repairs.
Wide Plank Flooring Is Best If You:
- Want a modern, open, and high-end aesthetic.
- Have a large space where wide planks can enhance the sense of openness.
- Appreciate the natural beauty of wood grain and unique textures.
- Are willing to invest in a more premium flooring option for long-term value.
If you’re still unsure about which option is best for your home, consulting with flooring experts can provide clarity.
Related Article: The Importance of Hiring a Professional Floor Installer for Your Hardwood Flooring
Maintenance Considerations for Both Flooring Types
Regardless of plank width, proper maintenance is crucial to preserving the longevity and beauty of hardwood floors. Here are some essential care tips:
- Regular Cleaning – Sweep and vacuum regularly to prevent dirt buildup and scratches.
- Use Proper Cleaning Products – Avoid excessive water and harsh chemicals that can damage the wood finish.
- Monitor Humidity Levels – Use a humidifier in dry seasons and a dehumidifier in humid months to minimize plank expansion and contraction.
- Protect the Surface – Use furniture pads and area rugs in high-traffic areas to reduce wear and tear.
- Refinish When Necessary – Over time, refinishing may be required to restore the wood’s appearance and protect against further damage.
Find the Perfect Hardwood Flooring for Your Home
Both narrow and wide plank hardwood flooring offer unique advantages, making them suitable for different home styles and preferences. Narrow planks provide a refined, traditional look with better stability in varying climates, while wide planks deliver a bold, contemporary feel that highlights the beauty of the natural wood grain.
When choosing between the two, consider factors such as room size, budget, and aesthetic goals. If you need professional guidance, LV Hardwood Flooring in Toronto offers a wide range of premium hardwood flooring options along with expert installation services.
Visit our showroom to explore different styles or contact us to find the perfect flooring to enhance your home’s beauty and functionality.
